To Cruise or Not To Cruise

      5 Comments on To Cruise or Not To Cruise
two couples ready for a canoe
Cruising the Dordogne River, France

It was this time last year we visited Bev and John in the south of France. While touring the Dordogne Valley, we looked into the future and started planning our next journey. None of us had been to Alaska. For John, it was the only state he hadn’t visited. For us, it could be a long road trip from the middle of Florida, across the lower 48, up through Canada into Alaska territory, in the van… yeah right.

We’ve all known someone who has been on an Alaska Cruise, right? It just may be a logical way to cover some Alaska territory. A cruise might be in the cards.

There are several reasons we had never been on a cruise prior to this Alaska tour. For us, the list included: lack of independence, buffet lines, environmental impact, cost and… well… all things distasteful of Americana (extravagance, abundance, and privilege.) Ultimately, cruising is not for everyone, but neither is our style of travel.

Our form of travel is budget/value, adventurous and probably pushes the comfort zone of most Americans.

With this in mind, I share my thoughts on the pros & cons of a cruise.

The Pros of Taking a Cruise

Let’s start on a positive note. There are some things we liked about taking a cruise. My favorite thing was unpacking once. Seven days, one bed and no lugging baggage – it’s really nice! Once onboard, all our entertainment needs can be met: there are cooking classes, live music concerts, trivia games, big screen movies, or going to a comedy show. People who are into gambling, ball room dancing, or yukking it up at a bar, all get their entertainment fix.

There is no debate about dining options, or “when” to eat. If you’re hungry, head to the grill. If it’s dinner time – your table is waiting. Food is going all the time: abundant, bottomless and pretty darn delicious.

Contrary to everything we’ve read about the tiny quarters of a stateroom, our room was big and luxurious. (Remember, we are budget travelers.) Our room had a big ole king size bed, a desk, mini fridge, loveseat, medium screen TV, private bath, ample closet space, and a large glass sliding door which opened to a 4×8 veranda with a glass banister. It was magnificent! The only time it felt small was navigating the hallway when room service delivered breakfast on their huge serving tray.

Ah yes, a room with a view, eating luxuriously with dessert every night, made us feel rich and indulgent.

The Cons

You are on someone else’s schedule. If a particular port calls to you, you would have to take note, and make plans to stay longer another day. Cruises are also quite insulating. It is difficult to get an authentic, cultural experience when you are limited to the boat, port and the shoreline jewelry shops. Of course, excursions give travelers opportunities to explore in depth, but those can be abbreviated opportunities. (Seize the chance to get off the beaten “onshore excursion” path and get ashore. Skip the costly excursions and explore the port on your own.)

Surrounded by Phony Store Fronts, means you just need to dig deeper

Another drawback are the (potentially) hidden costs of a cruise. Many amenities on the ship cost big bucks. Things like yoga classes, a facial, bar drinks (from coke to alcohol), even coffee – other than the drip variety – will cost you more. They don’t even show prices, making “a day in the spa” look like the only thing you need to do, is show up. We did some exhaustive homework before taking this cruise, asked a million questions. Easy missteps can wind up being expensive lessons.

To Cruise Or Not To Cruise

If you want a “vacation”, then a cruise will likely fit the bill. Check out our post on vacation vs travel, or 10 Steps to Create a Life of Travel. If you’re adventurous, enjoy authentic and cultural experiences, then a cruise will likely be less fulfilling. For us, I don’t see a cruise in the future forecast.

About Hali & Woody

We are a couple who took the first steps toward a life of traveling in May, 2015. Staying within the continental US to accommodate our aging dog, we amp’d up the adventure factor by traveling in a VW Vanagon, circa 1985. Our mission is to share irresistible and compelling stories conceived from this life of travel.

5 thoughts on “To Cruise or Not To Cruise

  1. Bevina

    Alaska was a good cruise to take because some of the sights are only navigable by boat — that was my favorite pro!

  2. Lois St. Sure

    The only cruise I took was with Susan. Otherwise, we like to stay in a place as long as we want. We like roaming through towns and eating where we wish. We like finding unusual restaurants. We usually see every museum and like to go back to the ones we especially liked. We don’t shop much except for funky places. I did like not having to pack too much, but we usually stay in a place for awhile so packing isn’t a big problem. All in all I guess cruises are not for us. I’ll wait until I’m old.

    I enjoy reading about your travels. I also like learning what your daughter is doing. She and Ely are still alike.


  3. Audrey P Adams

    Now you can say you did a cruise, then happily hop back in your Westy and take off for parts unknown. (There is a reason it’s called luggage — you have to lug it.)


We enjoy hearing from you! Leave a comment here:

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.